View the Mobile Version of M+N

Discussions

50 Shades of Grey

theneworphan  said about 9 months ago  or at  1:25PM on Monday, August 20 2012 in books

So has anyone read it out of perverse curiosity, or just out of perversion?

Why is it that men look at porn all the time, pretty much as an open secret, yet the instant there's a smutty piece of media popular among women, it's lambasted as crappy, base pap? I mean, porn made for men is not exactly high art.

Post your favourite passages here.

Here's some choice, fake ones from http://twitter.com/50shadesofshit and http://www.fiftyshadesgenerator.com/

''my vertical smile now much like a bucket of smashed crabs''

''He was cunt hungry & furiously ate my pussy, like a cannibal on bath salts eating a tramp's face off''.


black wasp!  said about 9 months ago:

my vertical smile now much like a bucket of smashed crabs
my vertical smile now much like a bucket of smashed crabs
my vertical smile now much like a bucket of smashed crabs
my vertical smile now much like a bucket of smashed crabs


woolfat  said about 9 months ago:

I want to read this.

theneworphan, have you read Story Of O? Sounds exactly the same as this but BETTER.


Sunnyboyz  said about 9 months ago:

Sometimes I wish porn occupied all top three places on worldwide bestseller lists.


happycow  said about 9 months ago:

Why is it that men look at porn all the time, pretty much as an open secret, yet the instant there's a smutty piece of media popular among women, it's lambasted as crappy, base pap?

I think it's being lambasted as crappy, base pap in the literary world, rather than the porn world.

Something like The Story of O, as wf mentioned, explores similar themes but has a much higher literary standing because it isn't so poorly written / fan-fiction-like.


woolfat  said about 9 months ago:

happycow, are you kidding? Story of O is TERRIBLY written. It just has notoriety status because it was penned by a man under a woman's name, and being written by a ''woman'' made it scandalous.


happycow  said about 9 months ago:

OK, there we go - it's obvious I know nothing about dom-lit written for women, but I'd still say it's the literary world lambasting 50 Shades, and not the porn world.


slothman  said about 9 months ago:

i tried reading some of it but it was just terrible.


happycow  said about 9 months ago:
  • and that lambasting is done based on the quality of writing, rather than the fact it's erotic.

woolfat  said about 9 months ago:

but still - EVERYONE READ STORY OF O. It's fantastically bad.


theneworphan  said about 9 months ago:

I've read The Story of the Eye, but I think that's from an entirely different set of pornolit


theneworphan  said about 9 months ago:

I was very excited when I first heard that 50 Shades of grey began its life as Twilight fanfic - says it all, really.


woolfat  said about 9 months ago:

Story of the Eye is totally different pornolit.


anonymous  said about 9 months ago:

delete this site.


slothman  said about 9 months ago:

what's the one where the guy gets a machine that can stop time and he uses it to sex on unsuspecting ladies?


goldfoot  said about 9 months ago:

Vox - Nicholas Baker


goldfoot  said about 9 months ago:

erm Nicholson Baker


hyperfuzz  said about 9 months ago:

Keep in mind that it was adapted from Twilight fan-fiction published under the name 'Snowqueens Icedragon'.


goldfoot  said about 9 months ago:

Erm, and it's The Fremata , not Vox.

I knew I shouldn't have opened this thread.


kelele  said about 9 months ago:

Haha, I once told a guy one of my favorite books was Story of the Eye (it's not) just to see how he reacted. He googled it on wiki and then left the bar pretty quickly after that.


LoadMyRig  said about 9 months ago:

terrible book. not even nearly erotic enough.


View Comments 20 to 47

We've limited the amount of comments shown in these larger topics to allow for faster viewing, simply click here to load all the missing comments ...

LoadMyRig  said about 9 months ago:

as much as i hate the motherfucking SHIT out of this book ..... JUST SAY a decent director got on board (bret pfft get off the oxys and the meth and let's talk) and JUST SAY a decent scriptwriter got involved who pumped up the scant actual eroticism in the story, and who JUST MAYBE took massive licence to make it an imminently more believable story and excised the fuck out of the goshes, and down-theres and my-inner-goddesses and my-subconsciouses ... then i might watch that film. possibly touch myself.

and i would appreciate it if alexander skarsgard played christian grey. thank you in advance.


toadphoney  said about 9 months ago:

Matt newton was born for that role.


LoadMyRig  said about 9 months ago:

a nation turns it's head and barfs


LoadMyRig  said about 9 months ago:

no apostrophe


toadphoney  said about 9 months ago:

No wonder australian talent has to head overseas. Too much violent round headed poppy syndrome on these shores.


GrantleyBuffalo  said about 9 months ago:

Paging losgauchos; losgauchos to the 50 Shades thread.


Wonky  said about 9 months ago:

Seconding Matt Newtown, that dude would rock.


TheBastard  said about 8 months ago:

When 50 Shades of gray is a common vernacular when discussing something, say in an article or review of something else does that fall into lazy journalist territory?

Am I using the word vernacular correctly by the way? I don't think I am, but it needs to be there somewhere


TheBastard  said about 8 months ago:

there needs to be an , after ''else''

sigh

gotta stop hitting enter so often and proof read


poprocks96  said about 8 months ago:

I had an epiphany and realised life is too short to bother finishing these books. I'm halfway through the trilogy and it shall remain that way. (they were a gift)


black wasp!  said about 8 months ago:


Shortpants Romance  said about 8 months ago:

I was in the 57 tram last week and I was reading this over a middle aged woman's shoulder. Wow. It was pretty juicy. I got an erection and had to tuck it into my belt.

Could have been embarassing.


yoghurt  said about 8 months ago:

should have told her you have a bookmark in your pants if she wants to use it


ocelotl  said about 8 months ago:

Great library pickup lines, #7.


TheBastard  said about 8 months ago:

yoghurt said 3 hours ago:
should have told her you have a bookmark in your pants if she wants to use it

How to win friends and influence people, No -109



pfinger18  said about 8 months ago:

50 Shades of Green: http://youtu.be/LvLQkuAFDlk


tugboat  said about 5 months ago:

George Takei reads 50 Shades http://youtu.be/7WahBH9sANg


iiii!  said about 4 months ago:

My old supervisor (who was, unsurprisingly, a 50 year old single woman) used to go on about these books all the time. And also occasionally try and bate me into discussing my sexual history. It was quite possibly the creepiest thing. Prior to that happening, I had no opinion of the books. Now I have a personal grudge against them.



You need to be logged into Mess+Noise to contribute to the Discussions.
Go on and Log In or if you you're not a member, feel free to Sign Up.

Today On Mess+Noise
MESS+NOISE on Facebook

The M+N Newsletter

Sign up for special offers, giveaways and exclusive tracks. The best spam you'll ever receive.